©2023 Victor R. Claveau, MJ
“Prejudice 1s a great time saver you don’t have to worry about facts.”
–St. Augustine (354-430)
Not long ago I had a short dialogue with a 9-year minister from Calvary Chapel. This individual lectures on Roman Catholicism. Upon review of his lecture, I sent him the following post:
“You not only misrepresented Catholic belief, but twisted and misrepresented history to support your conclusions. In your disagreement section you misrepresented the Catholic Church’s teaching on justification, the seven sacraments, faith alone, purgatory, intercessory prayer, Mary, and much more. I was especially disturbed by your presentation on the Bible. You not only misrepresent the Catholic view of the Bible, but also misrepresented the history of the Bible. You parroted Chuck Smith when he stated that the Catholic Church added the “Apocrypha” at the Council of Trent. Nothing could be further from the truth. In addition, you obviously have no understanding of Tradition as it impacted doctrine, and your chronological list of Church inventions is simply ridiculous.
His reply, “Nice assertions Victor. Try backing up the things you say below with some actual examples and facts. You obviously have never taken a critical look at the teachings and/or history of the Catholic Church. Looking forward to standing before the Lord, having been justified by His faith through His grace alone.”
I replied, “Your defensive response was as expected. I was rather hoping for one characterized by a certain humility. Rather than saying, “nice assertions, I would have preferred, “It is very important to me that I teach nothing but the truth, please show me where I have erred.” Unfortunately, your pride got in the way. I have yet to meet a Calvary Chapel minister who was willing to do what you ask me to do and that is taking a critical, honest, look at your own teachings, based upon the evidence. You would rather set up a Catholic strawman and then beat him to death.
What makes you think I have not taken a critical look at Catholicism? Long ago, I thoroughly examined Catholic beliefs and as God is my witness, I have never found any contradiction between what the Catholic Church teaches today and what Jesus and His Apostles taught so many years ago.
You asked for “some examples and facts.” It would take quite some time to deal with each and every error, as there are so many, so I will focus on just two of the more minor ones for the time being.” I then went on to prove that his “scholarship” was entirely in error.
He never replied, nor did he remove the offending material from his website. It takes intellectual integrity to examine one’s most cherished beliefs, to admit it when you have borne false witness against another, and to endeavor to make restitution. This man did none of these.
We Catholics must stand our ground and defend Mother Church whenever and wherever she is attacked either deliberately or in ignorance.
Prejudice
©2023 Victor R. Claveau, MJ
“Prejudice 1s a great time saver you don’t have to worry about facts.”
–St. Augustine (354-430)
Not long ago I had a short dialogue with a 9-year minister from Calvary Chapel. This individual lectures on Roman Catholicism. Upon review of his lecture, I sent him the following post:
“You not only misrepresented Catholic belief, but twisted and misrepresented history to support your conclusions. In your disagreement section you misrepresented the Catholic Church’s teaching on justification, the seven sacraments, faith alone, purgatory, intercessory prayer, Mary, and much more. I was especially disturbed by your presentation on the Bible. You not only misrepresent the Catholic view of the Bible, but also misrepresented the history of the Bible. You parroted Chuck Smith when he stated that the Catholic Church added the “Apocrypha” at the Council of Trent. Nothing could be further from the truth. In addition, you obviously have no understanding of Tradition as it impacted doctrine, and your chronological list of Church inventions is simply ridiculous.
His reply, “Nice assertions Victor. Try backing up the things you say below with some actual examples and facts. You obviously have never taken a critical look at the teachings and/or history of the Catholic Church. Looking forward to standing before the Lord, having been justified by His faith through His grace alone.”
I replied, “Your defensive response was as expected. I was rather hoping for one characterized by a certain humility. Rather than saying, “nice assertions, I would have preferred, “It is very important to me that I teach nothing but the truth, please show me where I have erred.” Unfortunately, your pride got in the way. I have yet to meet a Calvary Chapel minister who was willing to do what you ask me to do and that is taking a critical, honest, look at your own teachings, based upon the evidence. You would rather set up a Catholic strawman and then beat him to death.
What makes you think I have not taken a critical look at Catholicism? Long ago, I thoroughly examined Catholic beliefs and as God is my witness, I have never found any contradiction between what the Catholic Church teaches today and what Jesus and His Apostles taught so many years ago.
You asked for “some examples and facts.” It would take quite some time to deal with each and every error, as there are so many, so I will focus on just two of the more minor ones for the time being.” I then went on to prove that his “scholarship” was entirely in error.
He never replied, nor did he remove the offending material from his website. It takes intellectual integrity to examine one’s most cherished beliefs, to admit it when you have borne false witness against another, and to endeavor to make restitution. This man did none of these.
We Catholics must stand our ground and defend Mother Church whenever and wherever she is attacked either deliberately or in ignorance.
New Post
The Illiterati
The Fire That Burned in Rose Hawthorne’s Heart
Fanny Allen: The Daughter Who Knelt Before the Tabernacle
Voting Pro Life
The United States has 3,144 counties and county-equivalent jurisdictions, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. Today, more than 180 U.S. counties lack a resident Catholic priest. Go to: https://glenmary.org/ You can help by donating: https://glenmary.org/donate-to-catholic-missions…/
The Call Behind the Door
Select A Catagory