"A Good Result Can Never Justify
Intrinsically Unlawful Means"
Here is a Vatican translation of the address Benedict XVI gave Sept. 16,
2006 to the participants in the symposium on "Stem Cells: What Future for
Therapy?" organized by the Pontifical Academy for Life.
* * *
Hall of the Swiss, Castel Gandolfo
Saturday, 16 September 2006
Venerable Brothers in the Episcopate and in the Priesthood,
Distinguished Ladies and Gentlemen,
I address a cordial greeting to you all. This meeting with you, scientists and
scholars dedicated to specialized research in the treatment of diseases that are
a serious affliction to humanity, is a special comfort to me.
I am grateful to the organizers who have promoted this Congress on a topic that
has become more and more important in recent years. The specific theme of the
Symposium is appropriately formulated with a question open to hope: "Stem cells:
what future for therapy?".
I thank Bishop Elio Sgreccia, President of the Pontifical Academy for Life, for
his kind words, also on behalf of the International Federation of Catholic
Medical Associations (FIAMC), an association that has cooperated in organizing
the Congress and is represented here by Prof. Gianluigi Gigli, outgoing
President, and Prof. Simon de Castellvi, President-elect.
When science is applied to the alleviation of suffering and when it discovers on
its way new resources, it shows two faces rich in humanity: through the
sustained ingenuity invested in research, and through the benefit announced to
all who are afflicted by sickness.
Those who provide financial means and encourage the necessary structures for
study share in the merit of this progress on the path of civilization.
On this occasion, I would like to repeat what I said at a recent Audience:
"Progress becomes true progress only if it serves the human person and if the
human person grows: not only in terms of his or her technical power, but also in
his or her moral awareness" (cf. General Audience, 16 August 2006).
In this light, somatic stem-cell research also deserves approval and
encouragement when it felicitously combines scientific knowledge, the most
advanced technology in the biological field and ethics that postulate respect
for the human being at every stage of his or her existence.
The prospects opened by this new chapter in research are fascinating in
themselves, for they give a glimpse of the possible cure of degenerative tissue
diseases that subsequently threaten those affected with disability and death.
How is it possible not to feel the duty to praise all those who apply themselves
to this research and all who support the organization and cover its expenses?
I would like in particular to urge scientific structures that draw their
inspiration and organization from the Catholic Church to increase this type of
research and to establish the closest possible contact with one another and with
those who seek to relieve human suffering in the proper ways.
May I also point out, in the face of the frequently unjust accusations of
insensitivity addressed to the Church, her constant support for research
dedicated to the cure of diseases and to the good of humanity throughout her
If there has been resistance -- and if there still is -- it was and is to those
forms of research that provide for the planned suppression of human beings who
already exist, even if they have not yet been born. Research, in such cases,
irrespective of efficacious therapeutic results is not truly at the service of
In fact, this research advances through the suppression of human lives that are
equal in dignity to the lives of other human individuals and the lives of the
History itself has condemned such a science in the past and will condemn it in
the future, not only because it lacks the light of God but also because it lacks
I would like to repeat here what I already wrote some time ago: Here there is a
problem that we cannot get around; no one can dispose of human life. An
insurmountable limit to our possibilities of doing and of experimenting must be
established. The human being is not a disposable object, but every single
individual represents God's presence in the world (cf. J. Ratzinger, "God and
the World," Ignatius Press, 2002).
In the face of the actual suppression of the human being there can be no
compromises or prevarications. One cannot think that a society can effectively
combat crime when society itself legalizes crime in the area of conceived life.
On the occasion of recent Congresses of the Pontifical Academy for Life, I have
had the opportunity to reassert the teaching of the Church, addressed to all
people of good will, on the human value of the newly conceived child, also when
considered prior to implantation in the uterus.
The fact that you at this Congress have expressed your commitment and hope to
achieve new therapeutic results from the use of cells of the adult body without
recourse to the suppression of newly conceived human beings, and the fact that
your work is being rewarded by results, are confirmation of the validity of the
Church's constant invitation to full respect for the human being from
conception. The good of human beings should not only be sought in universally
valid goals, but also in the methods used to achieve them.
A good result can never justify intrinsically unlawful means. It is not only a
matter of a healthy criterion for the use of limited financial resources, but
also, and above all, of respect for the fundamental human rights in the area of
scientific research itself.
I hope that God will grant your efforts -- which are certainly sustained by God
who acts in every person of good will and for the good of all -- the joy of
discovering the truth, wisdom in consideration and respect for every human
being, and success in the search for effective remedies to human suffering.
To seal this hope, I cordially impart an affectionate Blessing to all of you, to
your collaborators and to your relatives, as well as to the patients who will
benefit from your ingenuity and resourcefulness and the results of your work,
with the assurance of my special remembrance in prayer.