The Evangelization Station

Best Catholic Links


Search this Site


Home


Contact


Feedback


Mailing List


Pray for Pope Francis


Scroll down for topics


100+ Important Documents in United States History


Anti-Catholicism


Apostolic Fathers of the Church


Articles Worth Your Time


 Biographies & Writings of Notable Catholics


Catholic Apologetics


Catholic Calendar


Catholic News Commentary by Michael Voris, S.T.B.


Catholic Perspectives


Catholic Social Teaching


Christology


Church Around the World


Small animated flag of The Holy See (State of the Vatican City) graphic for a white background

Church Contacts


  Church Documents


Church History


Church Law


Church Teaching


Demonology


Doctors of the Church


Ecumenism


Eschatology

(Death, Heaven, Purgatory, Hell)


Essays on Science


Evangelization


Fathers of the Church


Free Catholic Pamphlets


 Heresies and Falsehoods


How to Vote Catholic


Let There Be Light

Q & A on the Catholic Faith


Links to Churches and Religions


Links to Newspapers, Radio and Television


Links to Recommended Sites


Links to Specialized Agencies


Links to specialized Catholic News services


Liturgy

General Instruction of the Roman Missal


Mariology


Marriage & the Family


Modern Martyrs

Mexican Martyrdom


Moral Theology

****

Pope John Paul II's

Theology of the Body


Movie Reviews (USCCB)


New Age


Occult


Parish Bulletin Inserts


Political Issues


Prayer and Devotions


Pro-Life

****

Hope after Abortion

Project Rachel

****

Help & Information for Men

****


Rite of Christian Initiation for Adults


Sacraments


Scripture


Spirituality


The Golden Legend


Vatican


Vocation Links & Articles

 


What the Cardinals believe...


World Religions


Pope John Paul II

In Memoriam


John Paul II

Beatification


Pope Benedict XVI

In Celebration



Visits to this site


Official Church Statements regarding the Magnificat Meal Movement.

3 MARCH, 2000.   STATEMENTS BY THE CATHOLIC BISHOPS OF QUEENSLAND

29th JULY, 1999 AN OPEN LETTER CONCERNING THE MAGNIFICAT MEAL MOVEMENT

11 FEBRUARY, 1999 DECLARATION CONCERNING THE MAGNIFICAT MEAL MOVEMENT IN THE DIOCESE OF TOOWOOMBA

27 OCTOBER 1998 STATEMENT BY BISHOP WILLIAM MORRIS

25 SEPTEMBER, 1997 STATEMENT BY BISHOPS OF QUEENSLAND

25 JULY, 1997  PRESS RELEASE By William M Morris, DD, Bishop of Toowoomba

1 JULY, 1997  STATEMENT BY BISHOP MORRIS ON THE CHURCH'S POSITION RE THE MAGNIFICAT MEAL MOVEMENT.

PRAYER FOR MEMBERS OF THE MAGNIFICAT MEAL MOVEMENT
 
 

3 MARCH, 2000.

STATEMENTS BY THE CATHOLIC BISHOPS OF QUEENSLAND


On 11 February, 1999 The Bishop of Toowoomba, Bishop William Morris, published a letter informing the people of the results of his formal investigation of the claim to private revelations of Debra Geilesky of Helidon, and of the teaching and practices of the Magnificat Meal Movement which she founded. He very clearly taught on that occasion that "on the basis of all the information available it can only be concluded that the alleged apparitions associated with the Magnificat Meal Movement are devoid of any supernatural origin. The writings published by the Movement itself also lead to the inevitable conclusion that it neither had, nor desires, any place in the Catholic Church". This is a conclusion which the Bishops of Queensland would all endorse. 
Sadly, since then, some people have continued to believe the claims of Debra Geilesky which have increasingly become more at variance with Catholic faith, practice and spirituality. At present she is claiming that the Mass celebrated in our Parishes is invalid and that Catholics risk their eternal salvation by participation. Because the Eucharist is at the centre of the Church, such false teachings is in opposition to the very life of the Church itself.
We, therefore, urge all to withdraw from any association with this Movement and its teaching. We would wish to welcome all who have aligned themselves with this Movement back into full communion with the Church. We also ask other Catholics to pray for those who have been harmed by their association with this Movement and to reach out to them with Christ-like love and concern.

SIGNED
Archbishop Bathersby     Archbishop of Brisbane
Bishop William Morris     Bishop of Toowoomba
Bishop Raymond            Benjamin Bishop of Townsville
Bishop Brian Heenan      Bishop of Rockhampton
Bishop James Foley       Bishop of Cairns

3rd SEPTEMBER, 1999
PRESS RELEASE FROM REV BRIAN SPARKSMAN, Chancellor of the Diocese of Toowoomba

Bishop Peter Stasiuk, the leader of the Ukrainian Catholic Church in Australia, has advised the Diocese of Toowoomba of the intended visit to the Movement at Helidon of a speaker named Josyp Terelya. He is to be in the district from mid-September until early October.
In a statement issued through his Chancellor, Very Rev Olexander Kenez, Bishop Stasiuk voices his concern that Josyp Terelya will present himself as an authoritative member of the Catholic Church. The Bishop stresses that Josyp Terelya does not in any manner or form represent the Ukranian Catholic Church or in any other branch of the Catholic Church, and that he is not authorised in any way to speak on behalf of the Church. He cautions everyone against attending any talk by Josyp Terelya.

Rev Brian Sparksman, DCL. Chancellor

29th JULY, 1999
AN OPEN LETTER CONCERNING THE MAGNIFICAT MEAL MOVEMENT


The Magnificat Meal Movement founded by Mrs Debra Geilesky has been much in the news. In 1997, because so many people raised concerns, I set a Commission to investigate the Magnificat meal Movement. Late last year the Commission handed me its findings and I took these, along with publications of the Magnificat meal Movement, to Rome. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith supported my view that Catholic people should disassociate themselves from the Magnificat meal Movement saying "All this constitutes a clear danger to many good people". In light of the Vatican statements I still declare that the Magnificat Meal Movement is not of God.

I want to be quite clear that no Magnificat Meal Movement activity has any church approval. This includes dressing in the style favoured by them and appearing en masse at diocesan functions as though they are an approved religious community. Any silence by me on this subject could be taken as tacit encouragement or approval of the Magnificat Meal Movement.

Recently in Toowoomba leaflets were distributed advertising Youth for Eucharist '99, an event sponsored by an organisation called Corpus Christi International. Corpus Christi International was registered by Debra Geilesky and two of her Magnificat Meal Movement followers on 15 February 1999, as a business for "educational materials". It may simply be a coincidence that this new name appeared within days of the promulgation of my letter advising the findings of the Commission and of the Vatican. "Corpus Christi International" has no permission, or approval, to work within this Diocese. This event, and the organisation promoting it, are not part of the Catholic Church. It is a private event organised by a private organisation. I issue a strong caution to all to avoid it. I advise any young people who may be attracted to this event to find an alternative that does enjoy the support of the Catholic Church.

Many good people have been hurt by their association with the Magnificat Meal Movement. It is my wish that this new organisation will be recognised as "more of the same", simply an extension of the Magnificat Meal Movement activities, so that it will not be the cause of further division and hurt within the Church and wider civic community.

The Catholic Church holds the Eucharist and Eucharist devotion in highest honour. The Eucharist is the "source and summit of all Christian worship" as the Second Vatican Council said. Precisely for this reason the Church will guard this treasure jealously against any kind of abuse. I encourage all Catholics to develop their knowledge of, and authentic worship of, the Eucharist within the genuine forms approved by and promoted by the Church.

I have stated previously that the Magnificat Meal Movement has no permission to reserve the Blessed Sacrament at its premises in Helidon, nor does it have permission for the Eucharist to be celebrated there. No Priest, other than Father Ryan the Parish priest, or someone who replaces him, is authorised by the Church for any celebration of the sacraments in the parish of Helidon. That directive still holds.

Yours in Christ

William M Morris, DD
Bishop of Toowoomba

11 FEBRUARY, 1999
DECLARATION CONCERNING THE MAGNIFICAT MEAL MOVEMENT IN THE DIOCESE OF TOOWOOMBA

On September 1, 1997, I appointed a Commission to investigate the Magnificat Meal Movement and alleged supernatural apparitions to its founder and some of its members. In October 1998 the Commission presented its provisional findings to me. After studying this information I personally consulted with the Vatican Authorities on this matter.

On the basis of all the information available it can only be concluded that the alleged apparitions associated with the Magnificat Meal Movement are devoid of any supernatural origin. The writings published by the Movement itself also lead to the inevitable conclusion that it neither has, nor desires, any place in the Catholic Church.

After reviewing the same information and also publications of the Movement itself, the Vatican Authorities confirmed these findings. In a letter dated 12 January, 1999, the Secretary of the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith makes a number of responses.

The letter is obviously referring to a number of specific allegations of corruption in the literature of the Movement. These even include supposed admissions of corruption by the Pope himself.

The Secretary writes:

"The facts show serious distortions of truth in allegations of corruption in the Church."

He continues:

"There is an obvious lack of due respect and obedience to legitimate authority and a disregard for Church discipline. It is misleading, to say the least, that these attitudes should be presented as inspired by Our Blessed Lady. None of this can come from a good source.

All of this constitutes a clear danger to many good people who may be lead away from proper obedience and loyalty to the Church."

Therefore, concern for the spiritual welfare of the People of God leads me, as Bishop of Toowoomba, to repeat my request that Catholic people dissociate themselves from the Magnificat Meal Movement and its activities.

I invite my fellow priests and brothers and sisters to promote the worship of Christ present in the Blessed Eucharist, and the veneration of Mary, the Mother of God, in the many authentic forms which have been approved by the Catholic Church.

Signed:

William M Morris, DD

Bishop of Toowoomba

 

27 OCTOBER 1998
STATEMENT BY BISHOP WILLIAM MORRIS


Under ordinary conditions, priests in Australia are generally presumed to have faculties to administer the sacraments anywhere in Australia within the framework of the Catholic Church. Exceptions to this occur where there has been specific direction by any Bishop within his diocese in some way limiting those faculties or by virtue of a limitation indicated in the Code of Canon Law.

I have twice made public statements that the Magnificat Meal Movement is not a movement of the Catholic Church.

Neither I, nor any other Bishop in the world, can grant to any cleric the faculties to preach or administer the sacraments for any group which is not a recognised movement of the Catholic Church, nor give permission for the reservation of the Blessed Sacrament.

The only legitimate clergyman in the Catholic parish of Helidon is Father John Ryan, or someone who legitimately replaces him. Anyone else intending to minister in the parish must have my direct permission, or permission arranged through Father Ryan. For some time now, there have been requests for clergy visiting the Magnificat Meal Movement premises. The Magnificat Meal Movement has no right to dictate to the parish of Helidon how to celebrate any Sacramental Rite or Eucharistic Celebration, nor does it have permission from myself or any other Bishop, including Bishop Issam Darwish, to reserved the Blessed Sacrament on it premises, or in any private residence.

To my knowledge, the parish of Helidon always follows liturgical rites as set down in the Roman Missal or the Roman Ritual: Holy Communion and Worship of the Eucharist Outside Mass.

Given its public statements and actions, there is some considerable doubt as to whether the Magnificat Meal Movement is a genuine Christian movement. However, if the Magnificat Meal Movement wished still to become a recognised movement within the Catholic Church, the means are always there for it to do so.

William M Morris, DD

Bishop of Toowoomba

25 SEPTEMBER, 1997
STATEMENT BY BISHOPS OF QUEENSLAND


When people in the Church claim to experience supernatural visions, and then attract groups of followers because of these claims, the Church is always cautious and subjects such claims to rigid investigations.

The Church follows certain set procedures to ensure the veracity of all claims for the good of God's people.

This is happening in the Diocese of Toowoomba, where Bishop William Morris, acting exactly in accordance with Vatican procedures, has set up a Commission to examine the claims of Mrs Debra Geilesky. Mrs Geilesky leads the Magnificat Meal Movement and claims she has witnessed supernatural visions.

These Vatican guidelines constitute the only legitimate procedure in such cases. The only way Mrs Geilesky can receive Church approval is by co-operating with the Church process.

The Bishops of Queensland wish to express their support for Bishop Morris and pray that his endeavours will achieve a blessed result for all God's people.

25 JULY, 1997
PRESS RELEASE
By William M Morris, DD, Bishop of Toowoomba


I am deeply distressed for the residents of Helidon who today have been subject to a puerile protest by residents living in their midst who are members of a sect called the Magnificat Meal Movement.

The placards have been particularly distressing to the children of the Helidon community.

The protest has no grounds, for the spiritual needs of the parishioners of Helidon, who include individuals who are members of the Magnificat Meal Movement, have been met and looked after by the Church as they always have been.

In line with Church law and protocol and according to the steps laid out by the Vatican, I am setting up a Commission to investigate the practices and statutes of the Magnificat Meal Movement and the alleged apparitions and visions of Mrs Debra Geilesky, founder of the Movement.

William M Morris, DD

Bishop of Toowoomba

1 JULY, 1997
STATEMENT BY BISHOP MORRIS ON THE CHURCH'S POSITION RE THE MAGNIFICAT MEAL MOVEMENT.


In May 1996 I made a statement to the Diocese which was released to the Media and sent to the Bishops of Australia as well as various parts of the world. This statement was made to clarify the Church's position in its relationship with the Magnificat Meal Movement. I stated then and I state now, that the Magnificat Meal Movement is a private movement sponsored and founded by Debra Geilesky. It is of Debra and has absolutely nothing to do with the Catholic Church. There is no Church approval for the Magnificat Meal Movement or for the alleged private revelations and visions of Debra. Those who attend and participate in the practices of the Magnificat meal Movement do so as private individuals and not as members of the Catholic Church. Those who participate within the liturgical life of the Parish of Helidon do so as individuals and not as members of the Magnificat Meal Movement.

There has never been a response to my request of Debra for the statutes under which the Magnificat meal Movement operates nor has there been clarification concerning its financial situation. Half-truths and inconsistencies in various reports concerning Debra and her movement make it difficult to know what is true and what is not, thereby causing confusion in people's minds to its authenticity. This confusion continues by using such titles for Mary as Corredemtrix, Mediatrix of all Graces and Advocate.

On June 22 the Catholic Weekly reporting from the L'Osservatore Romano stated that a Commission was set up by the Vatican at the request of Pope John Paul II to investigate petitions sent to him from certain circles asking that Mary be formally proclaimed as "Mediatrix" (Mediator), "Corredemtrix" (Co-redeemer) and "Advocate". The Commission unanimously agreed that the Roman Catholic Church should not solemnly define new teachings about the Virgin Mary. The Commission's main objectives were that the titles as proposed are ambiguous, and that the Second Vatican Council, although initially asked to make the same solemn proclamation chose not to do so after study, prayer and discussion. It completely avoided referring to Mary as Co-redeemer and made only a very sober use of the titles Mediator and Advocate.

The Bishops of the Second Vatican Council and Pope John Paul II in his speeches and letters have preferred to describe Mary as "Cooperator" in Christ's work of redemption. Mary does have a role of Maternal Mediation on behalf of all believers but this is subordinate to the absolute and universal role of Christ. The Magnificat Meal Movement continually misleads its followers by saying that these titles are going to be defined by the Pope in the very near future.

Once again, this is clear evidence of the half-truths and inconsistencies in statements and reports made by the Magnificat Meal Movement. The Magnificat Meal Movement is no more authentically Catholic than a tennis club made up of predominantly Catholic members or a fishing club made up of predominantly Catholic members. The Magnificat Meal Movement uses traditional Catholic practices to entrap people into a sect or cult that is not Catholic. The confusion and the hurt surrounding Debra and her movement saddens me for there have been many who through traditional devotion to Eucharist and to Mary have experienced conversion of heart and deepened their faith in the Risen Lord. Unfortunately because of the half-truths, the inconsistencies and in some instances the lack of orthodoxy concerning aspects of statements made and practices performed, the Magnificat Meal Movement places itself outside the Catholic Church. the Magnificat Meal Movement has no standing within the Catholic Diocese of Toowoomba or within the Universal Catholic Church.

PRAYER FOR MEMBERS OF THE MAGNIFICAT MEAL MOVEMENT

All powerful and ever present God, we pray for the return of the members of the Magnificat Meal Movement to full communion with your Church. May the example of Mary, whose obedience, faith, hope and burning charity made her Mother of the Church, inspire them to follow in her footsteps, united with the Apostles and their successors.

We ask this through Christ Your Son.

Amen

Copyright 2004 Catholic Diocese of Toowoomba

 

webmaster  www.evangelizationstation.com

Copyright 2004 Victor Claveau. All Rights Reserved